Nutter Butter Pie

March 20, 2025

23

The moment you take a bite of Nutter Butter Pie, your taste buds will dance with joy. This creamy masterpiece combines the irresistible flavors of peanut butter and chocolate in a cookie crust that practically begs for your attention. Imagine the crunch of those delectable Nutter Butter cookies giving way to a rich and velvety filling; it’s like a party in your mouth where everyone’s invited.

Reflecting on my childhood, I remember the first time I devoured this pie at a family gathering. My cousin Sara had whipped it up, and as soon as I tasted it, I knew I had found my soulmate in dessert form. Whether it’s a birthday bash or just another Wednesday night, this is the kind of pie that brings everyone together—and trust me, they will be asking for seconds.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

This delightful Nutter Butter Pie is simple to make and requires minimal ingredients
The combination of sweet and salty flavors creates an unforgettable taste experience
Visually appealing with its luscious layers, it will steal the show at any gathering
Perfect for warm weather since there’s no baking involved—just chill and enjoy!

I still remember the looks on my family’s faces when they realized I had made an entire pie just for myself.

Recipe preparation

Essential Ingredients

Here’s what you’ll need to make this delicious dish:

Nutter Butter Cookies: These iconic cookies provide the base for your crust—crunchy yet soft enough to meld perfectly with your filling.
Unsalted Butter: Using unsalted butter lets you control the overall saltiness of your dessert while enhancing the cookie flavor.
Cream Cheese: Make sure it’s softened! This ingredient adds richness and creaminess that balances out the sweetness.
Powdered Sugar: Use this sweetener for an ultra-smooth filling that blends beautifully without any graininess.
Peanut Butter: Go for creamy peanut butter here; it elevates the flavor profile and keeps everything silky smooth.
Whipped Topping: Optional but recommended—this adds lightness to your filling and makes each slice feel like a cloud of bliss.

The full ingredients list, including measurements, is provided in the recipe card directly below.

Let’s Make it Together

Create Your Cookie Crust: Start by crushing 24 Nutter Butter cookies into fine crumbs using a food processor or ziplock bag and rolling pin. Pour these crumbs into a bowl and mix them with melted butter until they resemble wet sand.

Form the Crust: Press this mixture firmly into the bottom of a 9-inch pie pan evenly. Use your fingers or the bottom of a glass to ensure it’s compact enough to hold its shape once set.

Prepare Your Filling: In another bowl, combine softened cream cheese and peanut butter until smooth. Gradually add powdered sugar while mixing until fully incorporated; aim for that dreamy texture!

Add Whipped Topping (Optional): If using whipped topping, gently fold it into your mixture now. This step makes your filling light as air—think clouds at sunset!

Chill Time: Spread your filling over the prepared crust evenly. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 4 hours or overnight if you can resist diving in too soon.

Serve & Enjoy: Once chilled, slice yourself a generous piece of this delicious Nutter Butter Pie. Watch out for happy dance moments—the flavor explosion is real!

Cooking should be fun! Embrace those messy moments in the kitchen because that’s where some of life’s best stories begin!

You Must Know

This Nutter Butter Pie is not just a treat; it’s a conversation starter
The creamy, dreamy filling paired with crunchy cookies creates a delightful contrast
Plus, it’s super easy to make and perfect for impressing guests or indulging yourself

Perfecting the Cooking Process

Start by crushing the Nutter Butter cookies for the crust, then whip up the filling while it chills. This method streamlines your efforts and ensures everything comes together beautifully without stress.

Serving and storing

Add Your Touch

Feel free to swap in other nut-flavored cookies or add chopped peanuts for extra crunch. You can also experiment with flavored extracts like almond or hazelnut to take it to another level.

Storing & Reheating

Store your Nutter Butter Pie in an airtight container in the fridge for up to five days. If you want to freeze it, wrap it tightly; just be sure to let it thaw in the fridge before serving.

Chef's Helpful Tips

To achieve the perfect crust, ensure your cookie crumbs are finely ground for even texture
When mixing the filling, beat until fluffy for a light consistency that melts in your mouth
Lastly, let it chill overnight for best flavor development before serving

Memories of this pie always bring smiles; my friends fought over the last slice at our last gathering, declaring it a “must-make” every time!

FAQs

FAQ

Can I use different cookies for the crust?

Absolutely! Chocolate wafers or graham crackers can work wonderfully as substitutes.

How long should I chill the pie?

Chill the pie for at least four hours, but overnight is even better!

Is there a way to make this pie gluten-free?

Yes! Use gluten-free Nutter Butter cookies or any similar gluten-free alternatives available.

Print